In hot pursuit of dinosaurs: Tracking extinct species on ancient Earth via biogeography

One researcher at the University of Tokyo is in hot pursuit of dinosaurs, tracking extinct species around ancient Earth. Identifying the movements of extinct species from millions of years ago can provide insights into ancient migration routes, interaction between species, and the movement of continents.

How to track a dinosaur: By combining data from fossils and models of the ancient Earth, researchers can map
where ancient species may have migrated. This method, called biogeographical network analysis, converts
evolutionary relationships between species into geographical relationships. This method was used in
 research by Tai Kubo, Ph.D., a postdoctoral researcher affiliated with the University Museum
at the University of Tokyo [Credit: Caitlin Devor/The University of Tokyo]

"If we find fossils on different continents from closely related species, then we can guess that at some point there must have been a connection between those continents," said Tai Kubo, Ph.D., a postdoctoral researcher affiliated with the University Museum at the University of Tokyo.

A map of life - biogeography

Previous studies in biogeography -- the geographic distribution of plants and animals -- had not considered the evolutionary relationships between ancient species. The new method that Kubo designed, called biogeographical network analysis, converts evolutionary relationships into geographical relationships.

For example, cats and dogs are more closely related to each other than to kangaroos. Therefore, a geographical barrier must have separated the ancestors of kangaroos from the ancestors of cats and dogs well before cats and dogs became separate species.

Early Cretaceous biogeographical map of nonavian dinosaurs: During the Early Cretaceous period
(145-100 million years ago), nonavian dinosaurs likely migrated between Africa and Europe.
The results are part of research by Tai Kubo, Ph.D., a postdoctoral researcher affiliated
with the University Museum at the University of Tokyo [Credit: Tai Kubo et al. 2019]

Most fossils are found in just a few hot-spot locations around the world and many ancient species with backbones (vertebrates) are known from just one fossil of that species. These limitations mean that a species' fossils cannot reveal the full area of where it was distributed around the world.

"Including evolutionary relationships allows us to make higher resolution maps for where species may have migrated," said Kubo.

The analysis used details from evolutionary studies, the location of fossil dig sites, and the age of the fossils. Computer simulations calculated the most likely scenarios for the migration of species between continents on the Cretaceous-era Earth, 145 to 66 million years ago.

North and south divide

This new analysis verified what earlier studies suggested: nonavian dinosaurs were divided into a group that lived in the Northern Hemisphere and another that lived in the Southern Hemisphere, and that those two groups could still move back and forth between Europe and Africa during the Early Cretaceous period (145 to 100 million years ago), but became isolated in the Late Cretaceous period (100 to 66 million years ago).

During the Early Cretaceous period, there were three major supercontinents: North America-Europe-Asia, South America-Africa, and Antarctica-India-Australia.

Late Cretaceous biogeographical map of nonavian dinosaurs: By the Late Cretaceous period
(100-66 million years ago), nonavian dinosaurs were separated into Northern and Southern
hemisphere groups. European dinosaurs were isolated by rising sea levels at the time. The
results are part of research by Tai Kubo, Ph.D., a postdoctoral researcher affiliated with
the University Museum at the University of Tokyo [Credit: Tai Kubo et al. 2019]

By the Late Cretaceous period, only the North America-Europe-Asia supercontinent remained. The other supercontinents had separated into the continents we know today, although they had not yet drifted to their current locations.

"During the Late Cretaceous period, high sea levels meant that Europe was a series of isolated islands. It makes sense that nonavian dinosaur species differentiated between Africa and Europe during that time," said Kubo.

Kubo plans to complete additional biogeographical analyses for different time periods to continue tracking extinct species around the world and through time.

The findings are published in Systematic Biology.

Source: University of Tokyo [May 31, 2019]